Published: 2026
Series: Assistant to the Villain #4
Author: Hannah Nicole Maehrer
Illustrator: N/A
Genres: Fantasy, Romantasy, Romantic Comedy
Audience (Grade Levels): 9, 10, 11, 12, Adult
Number of Stars: 3-Star
Goodreads Link: Adversary to the Villain
Content Notes: Violence, murder, blood, torture, death, grief, parental abandonment, emotional abuse, and strong language
Review By: Sarah Wergin

Audience Note: This series is marketed primarily to adults. The reviewer recommends it for consideration for older teen readers and discusses its potential value for high school collections below.

Publisher’s Summary

HR Update: The position of “adversary to the villain” has been filled. Evie Sage does not recall applying. Evie has always tried to be helpful, loyal, and only mildly involved in treason. But with a dangerous prophecy threatening the very magic of Rennedawn – not to mention the race to claim its necessary artifacts before King Benedict does – things are starting to feel… less like a career path and more like a serious problem. The prophecy won’t stop pointing in Evie’s direction. The Villain’s magic keeps choosing her. And honestly, if you’re going to be accused of evil anyway, you might as well commit.

Unfortunately, the more Evie leans into her alleged villain era, the more her boss starts acting like the hero of a completely different story. Trystan is getting closer – closer than is wise, advisable, or even remotely professional – and looking at her like she’s already chosen a side. His. Which is deeply inconvenient, because if Evie can’t save the kingdom’s magic, she might just become its greatest threat.

Review

I’ve compared this series to a Hallmark movie from the very beginning: a little cheesy, occasionally ridiculous, and not necessarily a literary masterpiece, but somehow you find yourself completely invested and reaching for the next one. Unfortunately, Adversary to the Villain, the fourth installment in Hannah Nicole Maehrer’s Assistant to the Villain series, didn’t quite give me that same feeling.

The series follows Evie Sage, who takes a job working for the kingdom’s infamous Villain, Trystan Maverine. What begins as a quirky workplace fantasy filled with humor, mystery, and an INCREDIBLY slow-burn romance has evolved into a much larger story involving magic, prophecies, political intrigue, and the fate of Rennedawn. In this installment, Evie and Trystan continue navigating their complicated relationship while confronting the growing threats surrounding the kingdom and their own destinies.

I didn’t hate this book, but I didn’t love it either. Something about this installment felt different. The earlier stories had their fair share of chaotic moments, confusing fantasy elements, and questionable pacing, but there was a certain charm that made it all work. This time, the chaos felt less entertaining and more like the author was trying to cram too much into one book. There was SO much happening that the story felt rushed and cluttered. The earlier books had relatively straightforward plots, but now there are so many characters, perspectives, and interconnected storylines that I’m starting to lose sight of what made the series so enjoyable in the first place. The chaos used to be part of the charm. Now it feels like the chaos IS the plot.

Another thing I really wish this book had included was a quick recap of the previous installments. It jumps right back into the story, and I found myself struggling to remember certain details, characters, and plot points. I kept feeling like I had missed something or should have revisited the earlier books before starting this one. With how much the story has expanded, a little refresher would have gone a long way. I don’t necessarily need everything spelled out for me, but I also don’t want to feel like I need to study for an exam just to keep up with a cozy fantasy series! LOL.

That said, I am still BEYOND invested in Evie and Trystan. Their relationship has always been the highlight of these books for me, and that hasn’t changed. I love their chemistry, witty banter, and the way their characters have grown. Evie has evolved from a somewhat naive, chaotic assistant into someone more confident and willing to challenge expectations, while Trystan continues to reveal the softer, more vulnerable side beneath his villainous reputation. Their relationship explores themes of loyalty, trust, identity, and the idea that people are more than the labels society assigns them. I particularly appreciate the recurring questions about what makes someone a hero or a villain and whether our choices or circumstances ultimately define us.

From a school library perspective, I would recommend this series to high school students who enjoy fantasy, humor, fairy-tale settings, and romance without explicit sexual content. Although marketed primarily toward adult readers, the romantic content is relatively mild, making it accessible to many older YA readers. The cover art and playful titles are appealing and effectively communicate the whimsical, romantic tone of the series. The books could also spark interesting conversations about character development, moral ambiguity, identity, and the traditional hero-versus-villain narrative. In an ELA classroom or book club, students could explore how authors subvert familiar fairy-tale tropes or examine how different characters’ perspectives influence our understanding of right and wrong.

While the series isn’t particularly focused on cultural diversity or representation, its exploration of belonging, acceptance, and challenging assumptions offers opportunities for social-emotional learning discussions. Evie’s growing confidence and willingness to question expectations also provide an interesting example of personal growth and self-advocacy.

Ultimately, I think this installment suffered from trying to do too much. I’ve always been willing to overlook the choppy writing, cheesy dialogue, and occasionally confusing worldbuilding because these books were just so much FUN. They were comforting, entertaining, and easy to get lost in. This one didn’t quite capture that same magic for me.

Would I recommend it? Yes, but primarily to readers who are already invested in the series. I wouldn’t suggest jumping into this book without reading the previous installments, and I would honestly recommend a quick refresher before starting. For a high school library collection, I think the series has value as an entertaining, approachable option for students interested in romantasy, particularly those looking for something lighter than the darker or more explicit titles popular in the genre.

Will I read the next book? Of course! At this point, I’m four books deep, and I NEED to know how everything plays out. But there’s definitely a difference between eagerly anticipating the next installment because you absolutely loved the last one and continuing because you’ve already invested this much time in the story. LOL.

I’m still rooting for Evie and Trystan, and I’m hoping the final installment brings back some of the charm, humor, and character-driven storytelling that made me fall for this series in the first place.

Classroom & Curricular Connections

  • ELA / Characterization: Trace Evie’s growing confidence and Trystan’s vulnerability. Examine how their choices reinforce or challenge the labels assigned to them.
  • Genre / Fairy-Tale Tropes: Explore how humor, romance, and shifting perspectives complicate traditional depictions of heroes and villains.
  • Narrative Structure: Discuss how multiple perspectives and interconnected storylines affect pacing, clarity, and suspense.

Readalikes

  • The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune
  • Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber
  • A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas

Related Posts