Published: 2023
Author: Torrey Maldonado
Genres: Middle Grade, Realistic Fiction, Sports, Fiction, Family, Contemporary, Abuse, Friendship, Young Adult
Audience (Grade Levels): 5-6, Middle School
Number of Stars: 5 Stars
Goodreads Link: HANDS
Triggers: Domestic abuse, stepfamily conflict, threats of violence, physical fighting/boxing
Review By: Sue Kowalski
Publisher’s Summary: Trev would do anything to protect his mom and sisters, especially from his stepdad. But his stepdad’s return stresses Trev–because when he left, he threatened Trev’s mom. Rather than live scared, Trev takes matters into his own hands, literally. He starts learning to box to handle his stepdad. But everyone isn’t a fan of his plan, because Trev’s a talented artist, and his hands could actually help him build a better future. And they’re letting him know. But their advice for some distant future feels useless in his reality right now. Ultimately, Trev knows his future is in his hands, and his hands are his own, and he has to choose how to use them.
Review:
This book is perfect for a reader who prefers a realistic story with a mix of drama, sports, family, friends, and a character who has to dig deep to figure things out. It’s a quick (er) read rich with authentic dialogue that is contemporary but not uncomfortable for a school read. I listened to the audio and enjoyed the voice of the author himself and I know many students will, too. For readers who like a conflict that gets resolved rather quickly to a “happy ending,” this book will work well. For readers who prefer books that aren’t wrapped up nicely too quickly, this book might not be “enough”.
Likely could engage in an ongoing discussion about physical responses to problems vs. other ways to rise above, but that conversation might prompt students to say what they think teachers want to hear. Would be easy for students to share that “violence is not the answer” sentiment whether they believe it or not. Those who have engaged in violence to survive or protect themselves or others might be hesitant to share this view knowing it will be countered with a “why don’t you try…” response. So, as a class read might be hard to engage in an honest exchange about the story’s relatability, but for an independent read this could easily be a reasonable and impactful way for a student to connect to story.
Classroom & Curricular Connections:
- Social-Emotional Learning (Conflict Resolution & Self-Expression): This book offers a profound look into internal moral conflict, exploring the choice between a physical response to danger versus using creative talents to rise above. It provides an avenue for discussing self-preservation, safety, and how personal realities can clash with conventional advice.
- English Language Arts (Dialogue & Author’s Voice): The novel’s quick pacing and authentic, contemporary dialogue make it an excellent text for analyzing realistic fiction. Additionally, utilizing the audiobook narrated by the author himself allows classes to explore how an author’s vocal performance adds depth and cultural authenticity to character voices.
Extension Activity / Library Application:
- Independent Reading Connection Journal: Recognizing the reviewer’s insight that a whole-class setting might stifle honest discussion on violence and survival, this title should be utilized as an independent read or literature circle selection. Students can use private reading logs to reflect honestly on Trev’s choices without the pressure of performing for a group dynamic.
- “Hands to Build” Artistic Extension: Capitalizing on Trev’s identity as a talented artist, pair the book with an independent library activity where students create an artistic representation of their own future goals. They can trace or sketch their hands and fill the outline with images, words, or illustrations of what they hope to “build” or accomplish.
Diversity & Representation:
-
The novel powerfully supports representation and equity by highlighting the authentic, lived experiences of a young protagonist balancing urban community life, family trauma, and complex protective instincts. By presenting a realistic domestic conflict without judgment, it mirrors the sensitive realities of youth who have had to navigate high-stakes environments, giving meaningful voice to characters facing immediate, difficult decisions.
Readalikes:
- Tight by Torrey Maldonado
- What Lane? by Torrey Maldonado
- Ghost (Track series) by Jason Reynolds
