Published: 2025
Author: Jyoti Chand
Illustrator: Tara Anand
Genres: YA Fiction, Contemporary
Format: Graphic Novel
Audience (Grade Levels): 9, 10, 11, 12, Adult
Number of Stars: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Goodreads Link: Fitting Indian
Content Notes: Suicide attempts and frank discussions of suicide, mental health struggles, self-harm/cutting, domestic and physical abuse, alcohol use, and a compromising photograph
Review By: Anonymous
Publisher’s Summary
This debut teen graphic novel from social media influencer Jyoti Chand and rising star illustrator Tara Anand follows one girl’s journey navigating high school and her mental health within a traditional South Asian family. Perfect for fans of Netflix’s Never Have I Ever and Tillie Walden’s Spinning. An American Library Association’s 2026 A Feminist Book Project for Ages 0-18 book list pick! All Nitasha’s parents want is for her to be the perfect Indian daughter—something she is decidedly not. Everything she does seems to disappoint them, especially her mom. They just don’t get that she’ll never be like her doctor older brother. To make matters worse, she’s never quite felt like she belongs at school either, and lately, her best friend, Ava, and her crush, Henry, seem to be more interested in the rich new girl than in her.
Alcohol takes the edge off, but when that doesn’t work, Nitasha turns to cutting. She can’t stop asking Will she ever be enough for her friends or her family? Or even for herself? This authentic and powerful teen graphic novel shines a light on how harmful the stigma of mental illness is and how lifesaving a community that is honest about mental health can be.
Review
This book was not what I expected it to be, but I wasn’t disappointed with it either. I thought it would be about the struggles of fitting in in a school or community but it was that and much more about mental health. I was a bit taken aback by how open, aggressive, and realistic the depictions of suicide were. At one point in the story, the main character Nitasha is in a psychiatric facility and the dialogue between her and the roommate in the same hospital room was so frank, that I couldn’t believe the author would be writing words that mocked taking one’s own life; it seemed that the roommate was laughing at how many attempts she and others have made on their own lives and not succeeded. While not what I was expecting, I applaud the author for the realism being portrayed, as I have no doubt that this is exactly what some individuals are feeling and experiencing.
The main topic of this book revolves around gender stereotyping within the Indian (Asian) culture. Multiple generations of women are shown and the main message they are all delivered while growing up is to be “ a good girl.” Unfortunately, the main character doesn’t quite fit these standards. As a result of not fitting the standards, Nitasha, the main character, is involved in drinking which leads her to expose herself to a boy and be photographed while doing so. The embarrassment and constant bombardment of being told and insinuated that she “isn’t enough and not a good Indian girl” leads to her cutting and ultimately attempting suicide. Good does come of this terrible choice – breathe now – and a happy ending ensues, but I almost wish it didn’t end that way. The realism to the story was REAL and I don’t think all suicide attempts end as neatly and happily as this story projects. I do like that Nitasha does something good for other Indian (Asian) girls in her community as a result of her suicide attempt and opens that door”/opportunity for other women to get the mental health help they are otherwise denied, as the unwritten rule within the culture is to not talk about such things. Yes, inspiring, but I don’t see it as an overly realistic ending.
That said, I see this book having a place on the shelves in school social workers, guidance counselors, and any mental health facility offices. It makes for an opportunity to open discussion. At the very least, it shows individuals that are hurting and struggling with their own issues and mental health, that there is a choice for happiness, empowerment, and a new life.
Classroom & Curricular Connections
- ELA / Characterization: Examine how dialogue, family interactions, and peer relationships shape Nitasha’s understanding of herself.
- Visual Literacy: Analyze how text and illustrations communicate emotions, conflict, and changes in perspective.
- Critical Literacy: Explore the gender expectations depicted within Nitasha’s family and community, distinguishing these characters’ experiences from generalizations about Indian or South Asian cultures.
- Diversity & Representation: The novel centers a South Asian American teenager navigating family expectations, gender roles, belonging, and mental health. Discussion should recognize variation within Indian and South Asian families and communities rather than treating Nitasha’s experiences as universal. Its portrayal of distress also offers opportunities to examine how stigma can affect access to support.
Readalikes
- Tall Water by SJ Sindu
- Until We Meet Again by Lily Kim Qian
- Silenced Voices by Pablo Leon