Published: 2022
Author: Karen McManus
Genres: YA Fiction, Contemporary, Mystery, Thriller
Audience (Grade Levels): 10, 11, 12
Number of Stars: 5-Star
Goodreads Link: Nothing More to Tell
Content Notes: Mild romance, murder, blood, dead bodies, parental abandonment, and mentions of domestic violence
Review By: Liz Geist

Publisher’s Summary

Four years ago, Brynn left Saint Ambrose School following the shocking murder of her favorite teacher—a story that made headlines after the teacher’s body was found by three Saint Ambrose students in the woods behind their school. The case was never solved. Now that Brynn is moving home and starting her dream internship at a true-crime show, she’s determined to find out what really happened.

The kids who found Mr. Larkin are her way in, and her ex–best friend, Tripp Talbot, was one of them. Without his account of events, the other two kids might have gone down for Mr. Larkin’s murder—but instead, thanks to Tripp, they’re now at the top of the Saint Ambrose social pyramid. Tripp’s friends have never forgotten what Tripp did for them that day, and neither has he. Just like he hasn’t forgotten that everything he told the police was a lie.

Digging into the past is bound to shake up the present, and when Brynn begins to investigate what happened in the woods that day, she uncovers secrets that might change everything—about Saint Ambrose, about Mr. Larkin, and about her ex-best friend, Tripp Talbot. Four years ago someone got away with murder. More terrifying is that they might be closer than anyone thinks.

Review

Nothing More to Tell by Nancy McManus is a young adult suspense and murder mystery told from the perspectives of two high school seniors, Brynn Gallagher and Noah “Tripp” Talbot. Four years earlier, when they were in eighth grade, a beloved teacher, Mr. Larkin, was murdered. His body was discovered by Tripp and two other classmates. The story they gave police seemed simple and straightforward, and the murder was eventually blamed on a drifter. Fast-forward four years, and Brynn is now a high school senior with dreams of becoming a journalist. When she lands an internship with a true crime show, she pitches the idea of revisiting her former teacher’s murder. The show agrees to investigate the case, with Brynn taking on much of the research. As she digs into the past in an effort to uncover Mr. Larkin’s real killer, she begins to uncover a long list of suspects, some much closer to home than she would like.

I really enjoyed this book! It offers plenty of suspense, a touch of romance, and relatable high school themes that will appeal to teen readers. I particularly appreciated the supporting characters, who added depth and realism to the story. The pacing was well done, with chapters that were just the right length to keep the plot moving and readers engaged. McManus also does a nice job of alternating between the two perspectives, giving readers different viewpoints as the mystery unfolds. I think this book would appeal most to readers in grades 10–12, particularly because of its high school setting and its exploration of the divide between the “haves and have-nots.” Other themes include trauma, guilt, trust, and the burden of keeping secrets. I would recommend this book to older high school students, as some of the subject matter may be sensitive for certain readers. I would recommend this book for students who enjoy a good, contemporary thrilling mystery. It is definitely a book that would enrich school libraries.

Classroom & Curricular Connections

  • ELA / Narrative Perspective: Examine how alternating viewpoints influence suspense and readers’ understanding of Brynn and Tripp. Track what each character knows, reveals, or conceals.
  • Journalism / Media Literacy: Discuss the responsibilities involved in revisiting a crime for a public audience, including verifying claims, evaluating sources, and considering the people affected.
  • Diversity & Representation: The reviewer highlights socioeconomic differences through the divide between the school’s “haves and have-nots.” This offers a meaningful opportunity to examine class, privilege, and access to social power. Parental abandonment and differing family experiences also provide perspectives on how home circumstances can shape students’ lives beyond what classmates see.

Readalikes

  • Five Survive by Holly Jackson
  • The Cheerleaders by Kara Thomas
  • Truly Devious by Maureen Johnson

Related Posts